George Quinones.

2026-10-12

Medigap Plans G vs N vs High-Deductible G

By George Quinones — licensed Florida health & life agent

MedicareMedigapPlans

Since Plan F closed to newcomers in 2020, Medigap shopping has condensed onto three plans: G, the everything-but-the-Part-B-deductible flagship; N, its cheaper sibling with a few small copays; and high-deductible G, the same coverage behind a big deductible and a much smaller premium. The differences look small on a chart and decide thousands of dollars over a decade. Here is the honest line-by-line, with the Florida-specific catch.

Plan GPlan NHigh-Deductible G
Part A deductible & coinsuranceCoveredCoveredAfter deductible
Part B coinsurance (20%)CoveredCoveredAfter deductible
Part B annual deductibleYou payYou payYou pay
Office visit copaysNoneUp to $20After deductible
ER copayNoneUp to $50 (waived if admitted)After deductible
Part B excess chargesCoveredNot coveredAfter deductible
Typical premiumHighestMidLowest

Plan G: the standard answer

G covers essentially everything Original Medicare charges: the Part A deductible and hospital coinsurance, skilled nursing coinsurance, the first three pints of blood, foreign travel emergencies, and all Part B coinsurance — everything except the small annual Part B deductible, which you pay yourself. Doctor bills are simple: if Medicare assigns it, G fills it, including the extra up to 15% that non-participating doctors can charge. For people who want a Medigap plan to mean what Medigap means, G is it.

Plan N: trading copays for premium

N covers the same list as G with three deliberate gaps: up to a $20 copay per office visit, up to a $50 emergency-room copay (waived if you are admitted), and no coverage of Part B excess charges — that 15% extra some doctors bill above Medicare's approved amount. Premiums typically run meaningfully below G, which is the entire proposition: pay small known copays and accept one open-ended exposure to save every month.

That exposure is not theoretical everywhere: several states effectively bar excess charges, but Florida is not one of them — non-participating providers here can bill them, so an N enrollee in Florida should know the risk is real, if uncommon in practice outside some specialties.

High-deductible G: catastrophe insurance

HDG is Plan G's benefits sitting behind a deductible in the high-two-to-low-three-thousand range, indexed annually. Until you meet it in a calendar year, you pay Medicare's cost-sharing yourself; after it, the plan pays like G. Premiums are dramatically lower — often half of standard G — which makes the math a bet: healthy years save the full premium difference, and one bad year costs roughly the deductible. Because it qualifies as high-deductible coverage, HDG can also preserve the ability to contribute to a health savings account, a pairing some retirees use deliberately.

Choosing among them

Heavy users of care — chronic conditions, scheduled surgeries — usually land in G, where the premium difference is smaller than the cost-sharing N leaves open. Moderate users who see doctors occasionally and accept the excess-charge caveat often save real money in N. HDG suits people who want hospitalization covered and routine costs to be theirs, and who have the cash to self-insure the deductible. Two rules apply to all three: the six-month open enrollment from Part B start is when you buy any of them without health questions, and the premium quoted is only half the story — ask how the carrier prices (community-rated versus attained-age) because that decides how fast it climbs. Comparing current G, N, and HDG pricing in your county is a standard plan review exercise.

Educational information only — not insurance, tax, or legal advice for your specific situation.